Rubric

Keep in mind that 45 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
A15 - 100% Front End Documents, Technical Specifications, Drawings, and ABET Calcs
A15 - 100% Front End Documents, Technical Specifications, Drawings, and ABET Calcs
Criteria Ratings Pts
1. Utilized appropriate base documents as directed.
threshold: pts
20 pts Exceeded Expectations
18 pts Met Expectations
16 pts Met Expectations
14 pts Met Expectations
12 pts Did not Meet Expectations
8 pts No Evidence of Work
pts
20 pts
--
2. Included all required front end sections revised to meet specific project requirements.
threshold: pts
30 pts Exceeded Expectations
27 pts Met Expectations
24 pts Met Expectations
21 pts Met Expectations
18 pts Did Not Meet Expectations
12 pts No Evidence of Work
pts
30 pts
--
3. Included technical sections revised to meet specific project requirement to describe parts of 4 civil engineering technical areas.
threshold: pts
30 pts Exceeded Expectations
27 pts Met Expectations
24 pts Met Expectations
21 pts Met Expectations
18 pts Did Not Meet Expectations
12 pts No Evidence of Work
pts
30 pts
--
4. Created project-specific documents that allow construction of a portion of the recommended solution?
threshold: pts
70 pts Exceeded Expectations
63 pts Met Expectations
56 pts Met Expectations
49 pts Met Expectations
42 pts Did Not Meet Expectations
28 pts No Evidence of Work
pts
70 pts
--
5. Effectively organized the submittal, with contract documents and drawings in the proper sequence?
threshold: pts
60 pts Exceeded Expectations
54 pts Met Expectations
48 pts Met Expectations
42 pts Met Expectations
36 pts Did Not Meet Expectations
24 pts No Evidence of Work
pts
60 pts
--
6. Effectively delivered the document and drawings?
threshold: pts
60 pts Exceeded Expectations
54 pts Met Expectations
48 pts Met Expectations
42 pts Met Expectations
36 pts Did Not Meet Expectations
24 pts No Evidence of Work
pts
60 pts
--
7. Submittal includes signed submittal letter?
threshold: pts
2 pts Met Expectations
0 pts Did not meet Expectations
pts
2 pts
--
8. Bid documents include table of contents with technical specification divisions appropriate to the project? Although a complete set of specifications is not expected, teams are expected to provide a complete list of the technical specifications that would be needed for the project.
threshold: pts
2 pts Met Expectations
0 pts Did not meet Expectations
pts
2 pts
--
9. Bid documents include a complete list of drawings needed for the work?
threshold: pts
2 pts Met Expectations
0 pts Did not meet Expectations
pts
2 pts
--
10. Bid documents include invitation to bid with a description of the work?
threshold: pts
2 pts Met Expectations
0 pts Did not meet Expectations
pts
2 pts
--
11. Bid documents include instructions to bidders, including project milestone schedule consistent with the separately submitted Gantt chart?
threshold: pts
2 pts Met Expectations
0 pts Did not meet Expectations
pts
2 pts
--
12. Bid documents include bid form for general prime contractor (GPC)?
threshold: pts
2 pts Met Expectations
0 pts Did not meet Expectations
pts
2 pts
--
13. Bid documents include sealed bid envelope label?
threshold: pts
2 pts Met Expectations
0 pts Did not meet Expectations
pts
2 pts
--
14. Bid documents include GPC bid bond?
threshold: pts
2 pts Met Expectations
0 pts Did not meet Expectations
pts
2 pts
--
15. Bid documents include designation of confidential/proprietary information?
threshold: pts
2 pts Met Expectations
0 pts Did not meet Expectations
pts
2 pts
--
16. Bid documents include affidavit of compliance with minority business enterprise and disabled veteran-owned business requirements?
threshold: pts
2 pts Met Expectations
0 pts Did not meet Expectations
pts
2 pts
--
17. Bid documents include request for submittal approval?
threshold: pts
2 pts Met Expectations
0 pts Did not meet Expectations
pts
2 pts
--
18. Bid documents include request for subcontractor approval?
threshold: pts
2 pts Met Expectations
0 pts Did not meet Expectations
pts
2 pts
--
19. Contract form includes performance bond?
threshold: pts
2 pts Met Expectations
0 pts Did not meet Expectations
pts
2 pts
--
20. Contract form includes payment bond?
threshold: pts
2 pts Met Expectations
0 pts Did not meet Expectations
pts
2 pts
--
21. Contract form includes construction contract?
threshold: pts
2 pts Met Expectations
0 pts Did not meet Expectations
pts
2 pts
--
22. Contract conditions include general conditions of the GPC contract?
threshold: pts
2 pts Met Expectations
0 pts Did not meet Expectations
pts
2 pts
--
23. Contract conditions include supplementary general conditions, using appropriate state or federal form?
threshold: pts
2 pts Met Expectations
0 pts Did not meet Expectations
pts
2 pts
--
24. Specification follows Division 01 - General Requirements that reflect action conditions and requirements of the project?
threshold: pts
2 pts Met Expectations
0 pts Did not meet Expectations
pts
2 pts
--
25. At least four of the following:
Related to construction engineering?

Related to environmental engineering?

Related to geological engineering?

Related to geospatial or surveying work?

Related to hydraulic design?

Related to hydrology/storm water design?

Related to structural engineering?

Related to transportation engineering?
threshold: pts
12 pts All Four Included
9 pts Three Included
6 pts Two Included
3 pts One Included
0 pts None Included
pts
12 pts
--
26. Contract addenda - blank form
threshold: pts
2 pts Met Expectations
0 pts Did not meet Expectations
pts
2 pts
--
27. Cover sheet with project location and contents expected in a complete drawing set?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met Expectations
0 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
28. General sheets with legends, as needed?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met Expectations
0 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
29. North arrows on all plan images?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met Expectations
0 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
30. Scale bar and/or dimensions for all images?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met Expectations
0 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
31. Student work disclaimer on every sheet?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met Expectations
0 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
32. Was all text readable and spelled correctly?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met Expectations
0 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
33. Were all lines readily visible?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met Expectations
0 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
34. A sufficient number of drawings to show the team understood project constructability? A complete drawing set is not expected (although the cover sheet should list what is expected in a complete set - see above).
threshold: pts
10 pts Met Expectations
0 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
35. ABET Requirement: Documented the solution of a differential equation and documented the application of the differential equation to the solution of an engineering problem for this project?
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeds Expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met Expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did Not Meet Expectations
4 pts No Evidence of Work
pts
10 pts
--
36. ABET Requirement: Documented the solution of a calculus-based physics problem and documented the application of the physics problem to the solution of an engineering problem for this project?
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeds Expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met Expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did Not Meet Expectations
0 pts No Evidence of Work
pts
10 pts
--
37. ABET Requirement: Documented the solution of a chemistry problem and documented the application of the chemistry problem to the solution of an engineering problem for this project?
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met Expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did Not Meet Expectations
4 pts No Evidence of Work
pts
10 pts
--
38. ABET Requirement: Documented the solution of a biology or geology problem and documented the application of the biology or geology problem to the solution of an engineering problem for this project?
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met Expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did Not Meet Expectations
4 pts No Evidence of Work
pts
10 pts
--
39. Included Opinion of Probable Cost?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did Not Meet Expectations
pts
10 pts
--
40. Included a Project Schedule?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did Not Meet Expectations
pts
10 pts
--