Rubric

A13 - Final Presentation Rubric
A13 - Final Presentation Rubric
Criteria Ratings Pts
1. Presented a summary of the alternatives discussed at the Preliminary Design Report Presentation?
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectation
8 pts Met Expectation
7 pts Met Expectation
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
2. Presented and addressed the judges questions and comments made during the Preliminary Design Report Presentation?
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectation
8 pts Met Expectation
7 pts Met Expectation
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
3. Reviewed the recommended solution with any modifications, by providing compelling, logical, credible, and audience-appropriate justifications for recommending the selected solution?"
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectation
8 pts Met Expectation
7 pts Met Expectation
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
4. Broke down a system into its component parts, such that its performance could be understood by the audience?
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectation
8 pts Met Expectation
7 pts Met Expectation
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
5. Analyzed well-defined engineering problems in at least four technical areas appropriate to civil engineering?
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectation
8 pts Met Expectation
7 pts Met Expectation
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
6. Solved well-defined engineering problems in at least four technical areas appropriate to civil engineering?
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectation
8 pts Met Expectation
7 pts Met Expectation
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
7. Used modern codes and standards as a tool to solve an engineering problem?
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectation
8 pts Met Expectation
7 pts Met Expectation
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
8. Created an updated realistic schedule of construction with critical path items appropriate to the project?
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectation
8 pts Met Expectation
7 pts Met Expectation
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
9. Created an updated and realistic opinion of probable cost appropriate to the project?
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectation
8 pts Met Expectation
7 pts Met Expectation
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
10. Effectively organized an oral presentation with logical flow? In assessing performance, please consider whether the presentation: 1. Included an introduction of team members who defined their responsibilities for both the project and the presentation. 2. Identified and integrated the desired needs of the project and stated the recommended solution from prelim design. 3. Made wise use of time for each item to be discussed.
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectation
8 pts Met Expectation
7 pts Met Expectation
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
11. Effectively delivered the content of an oral presentation? In assessing performance, please consider whether the presentation: 1. Provided clear, emphatic, efficient oral delivery of technical information. 2. Identified and created suitable graphics and equations and integrated them usefully to clarify technical concepts. 3. Contained effectively designed slides for technical presentations with readable text. 4. Showed ability of individuals to work well as a team. 5. Professionally responded to judges’ questions and professionally interacted with judges.
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectation
8 pts Met Expectation
7 pts Met Expectation
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
12. Understood the importance of professional attire?
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectation
8 pts Met Expectation
7 pts Met Expectation
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--