Rubric

Keep in mind that 46 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
A09 - 75% Front End Documents, Technical Specifications, and ABET Calculations Rubric
A09 - 75% Front End Documents, Technical Specifications, and ABET Calculations Rubric
Criteria Ratings Pts
1. Utilized appropriate base documents as directed.
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectation
8 pts Met Expectation
7 pts Met Expectation
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
2. Included all required front end sections revised to meet specific project requirements,
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectation
8 pts Met Expectation
7 pts Met Expectation
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
3. Included technical sections revised to meet specific project requirement to describe parts of 4 civil engineering technical areas.
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectation
8 pts Met Expectation
7 pts Met Expectation
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
4. Created project-specific documents that allow construction of a portion of the recommended solution?
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectation
8 pts Met Expectation
7 pts Met Expectation
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
5. Effectively organized the submittal, with contract documents in the proper sequence?
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectation
8 pts Met Expectation
7 pts Met Expectation
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
6. Effectively delivered the document?
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectation
8 pts Met Expectation
7 pts Met Expectation
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
7. Signed submittal letter?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
8. Cover page?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
9. Student work disclaimer?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
10. Concise summary of work?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
11. Table of contents with technical specification divisions appropriate to the project? Although a complete set of specifications is not expected, teams are expected to provide a complete list of the technical specifications that would be needed for the project. "
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
12. A complete list of all drawings needed for the project.
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
13. Invitation to bid with a description of the work?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
14. Instructions to bidders, including project milestone schedule consistent with the separately submitted Gantt chart?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
15. Bid form for general prime contractor (GPC)?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
16. Sealed bid envelope label?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
17. GPC bid bond?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
18. Designation of confidential/proprietary information?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
19. Affidavit of compliance with minority business enterprise and disabled veteran-owned business requirements?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
20. Request for submittal approval?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
21. Request for subcontractor approval?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
22. Performance bond?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
23. Payment bond?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
24. Construction contract?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
25. General conditions of the GPC contract?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
26. Supplementary general conditions, using appropriate state or federal form?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
27. Division 01 – General Requirements that reflect the actual conditions and requirements of the project?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
28. Specification related to four or more of the following: (A) construction engineering, (B) environmental engineering, (C) geological engineering, (D) geospatial or surveying, (E) hydraulic or hydrologic engineering, (F) structural engineering, (G) transportation engineering.
threshold: pts
70 pts Exceeded expectations (included more than four areas)
60 pts Met Expectations (included four areas)
40 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
70 pts
--
29. Contract addenda – blank form
threshold: pts
10 pts Met expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
pts
10 pts
--
30. ABET Requirement: Documented the solution of a differential equation and documented the application of the differential equation to the solution of an engineering problem for this project?
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met Expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did Not Meet Expectations
4 pts No Evidence of Work
pts
10 pts
--
31. ABET Requirement: Documented the solution of a calculus-based physics problem and documented the application of the physics problem to the solution of an engineering problem for this project?
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met Expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did Not Meet Expectations
4 pts No Evidence of Work
pts
10 pts
--
32. ABET Requirement: Documented the solution of a chemistry problem and documented the application of the chemistry problem to the solution of an engineering problem for this project?
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met Expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did Not Meet Expectations
4 pts No Evidence of Work
pts
10 pts
--
33. ABET Requirement: Documented the solution of a biology or geology problem and documented the application of the biology or geology problem to the solution of an engineering problem for this project?
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded Expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met Expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did Not Meet Expectations
4 pts No Evidence of Work
pts
10 pts
--
34. Included an Opinion of Probable Cost?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did Not Meet Expectations
pts
10 pts
--
35. Included a Project Schedule?
threshold: pts
10 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did Not Meet Expectations
pts
10 pts
--