Rubric

Keep in mind that 46 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
A11 - 75%, 100% Soils Report Rubric
A11 - 75%, 100% Soils Report Rubric
Criteria Ratings Pts
1. Project description relative to geotech issues
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
2. Local geology (soil, glacial status and bedrock depth)
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
3. Description of investigation program
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
4. Boring logs and boring location plan
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
5. Surface characteristics of site (topography, history, nearby features / structures, evidence of contamination)
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
6. Subsurface profile from exporation program (soil / rock, layers, lab test data, evidence of possible contamination)
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
7. Groundwater conditions (depth, flow direction, and influencing factors)
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
8. Recommended foundation and floor slab support, including alternatives considered
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
9. Foundation detail drawing
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
10. If shallow foundations: allowable bearing pressure, bearing capacity, settlement (all with calculations) or, If deep foundations: pile alternatives, typical design capacity, estimated lengths (all with calculations)
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
11. Site preparation recommendations: clearing, stripping, proof-rolling, removal of unsuitable material)
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
12. Potential construction issues (e.g. on-site fill sources, removal of poor soils, potential impacts of weather, dewatering recommendations)
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
13. Earth pressure coefficients for design of below grade structures (such as basements and retaining walls)
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--
14. Effectively delivered a written document? In assessing performance please consider whether the document: Identified and created suitable graphics and equations and integrated them usefully to clarify technical concepts. Employed clear, concise, unambiguous, and cohesive writing (with emphasis on correct mechanics and fluid style). Was free of spelling errors.
threshold: pts
10 pts Exceeded expectations
9 pts Met Expectations
8 pts Met expectations
7 pts Met Expectations
6 pts Did not meet expectations
4 pts No evidence of work
pts
10 pts
--